Back to Blog
Fees & Surcharges article cover: Best Shopify Extra Fee and Surcharge Apps (2026 Comparison)

Best Shopify Extra Fee and Surcharge Apps (2026 Comparison)

Bony Team•November 12, 2026•7 min read

Compare Shopify apps for extra fees, surcharges, handling and payment fees: pricing, free plans, POS support, payment-method fees and Built for Shopify status.

Shopify has no built-in way to add extra fees or surcharges with rules. If you want to charge a handling fee, a tariff surcharge, a deposit, or a COD fee, you need an app.

There are dozens of fee apps on the Shopify App Store. They look similar at first, but they differ in what matters day to day: which channels they cover, how they price, and what happens when your store grows.

We compared six apps that show up for searches like "extra fee", "surcharge" and "payment fee".

Disclosure: we make Bony Surcharge & Tariff Fees, one of the apps in this list. We've used each app's public App Store listing as of 12 November 2026 for prices, reviews and features, and we point out where other apps are a better fit. Prices and reviews change, so check the listing before you install.

Quick comparison

AppRating (reviews)Free planCheapest paid planShopify POSPayment-method feesBuilt for Shopify
Bony Surcharge & Tariff Fees5.0 (16)10 fee orders/month, Online Store only$5.99/mo, 100 fee ordersPaid plansYes, on Shopify PlusYes
VOL Surcharge Fee & Extra Fees5.0 (101)10 fee orders/month, Online Store only$15/moPaid plansYes, on its Plus tierYes
Upcharge Surcharge Fee Tariff4.8 (203)Development stores only$9.99/mo, unlimited feesYesYes, incl. CODYes
TackOn: Cart Fees & Surcharges4.3 (5)20 orders/month$5/mo, 50 orders + $0.10/extra orderNot listedNot listedYes
Kai: Extra Fees & Surcharges4.0 (1)1 active fee$5.99/mo, unlimited feesYesNot listedNo
Feesly: Surcharges & Card Fees3.7 (15)No$0.99/moYesCard surchargesNo

"Not listed" means the listing doesn't mention it. The app may still support it, so ask the developer.

How to choose a fee app

Answer these five questions first:

  1. Where do you sell? Online only, or also in person with Shopify POS and B2B draft orders?
  2. What triggers the fee? Specific products, cart total, customer tags, market or country, or the payment method?
  3. How many orders will carry a fee? Order-capped plans are cheap for small stores but can get expensive as you grow.
  4. Are you on Shopify Plus? Fees that react to the payment or shipping method during checkout need Plus, whichever app you use.
  5. Do customers need a choice? Optional add-ons like gift wrap or insurance need checkbox or dropdown options.

The apps in detail

Bony Surcharge & Tariff Fees

Bony adds each fee as its own line item, so product prices never change. It covers product fees and once-per-order fees, with fixed or percentage amounts.

Strengths

  • One set of rules across channels: Online Store, Shopify Plus checkout, POS (manual or automatic fees by location) and Draft Orders.
  • Detailed targeting: product, variant, collection, cart total, customer tag, market, and the shopper's shipping country or region.
  • Payment and shipping method fees on Shopify Plus. See our credit card fee guide and COD fee guide.
  • Optional add-ons with checkbox, dropdown or radio options, each with its own price.
  • Product fee charge modes: per unit, once per variant, or once per product.
  • Storefront translations, so fee labels match each language.
  • Lowest price among the Built for Shopify apps here.

Trade-offs

  • Fewer reviews than VOL and Upcharge, because Bony launched in July 2026.
  • The 7-day trial is shorter than Upcharge's 14 days and TackOn's or Feesly's 30 days.
  • Paid plans cap monthly fee orders (100 on Starter, 200 on Growth). Unlimited orders need the $24.99 Plus plan.

Best for: stores that sell on more than one channel and want detailed targeting at a low price.

VOL Surcharge Fee & Extra Fees

VOL is the most similar app to Bony in this list. It covers product, handling and order fees across the online store, POS and Draft Orders, and it has strong reviews.

  • Free plan: up to 10 orders with fees a month, online store only.
  • Pro is $15/month and adds POS and Draft Order fees. A $35/month Plus plan for Shopify Plus stores adds payment-method fees.
  • POS fees can be applied or excluded by store location.

Best for: merchants who want an established app with many reviews and don't mind paying more than Bony.

Upcharge Surcharge Fee Tariff

Upcharge has the most reviews in this comparison. Its Basic plan includes unlimited fees and surcharges for $9.99/month, with a 14-day free trial.

  • Names many fee types on its listing: credit card surcharges, payment method fees, COD fees, tariff surcharges.
  • POS-compatible fees and customer tag conditions.
  • A $29.99/month plan for Shopify Plus adds fees based on payment and shipping method.
  • The free plan is for development stores only.

Best for: stores with many orders that want unlimited fees on a flat monthly price.

TackOn: Cart Fees & Surcharges

TackOn has the most generous order-capped free plan here: 20 orders a month on a live store. The Starter plan is $5/month with 50 orders, then $0.10 per extra order, and a 30-day trial.

  • Fixed, percentage or combined fee types.
  • Works with Shopify Markets for multi-currency, and lists an UpCart integration.
  • The listing doesn't mention POS or payment-method fees.

Best for: small online-only stores that want to try fees for free for longer.

Kai: Extra Fees & Surcharges

Kai offers unlimited active fees for $5.99/month and a free plan with one active fee.

  • Mandatory fees or optional add-ons shown as a checkbox, toggle or popup.
  • Market-based fees shown in local currency, and a fee revenue dashboard.
  • POS compatibility, including on the free plan.
  • No Built for Shopify badge, very few reviews so far, and a 4-day trial.

Best for: stores that need many simple fees on a fixed budget.

Feesly: Surcharges & Card Fees

Feesly is the cheapest app here at $0.99/month, with a 30-day trial and all features on one plan.

  • One-tap POS fees, or a POS tile that applies a default fee itself.
  • Online fees on products or as a separate order fee.
  • Fee reports you can filter by date and location and export.
  • No free plan, no Built for Shopify badge, and a lower rating than the others.

Best for: POS-focused stores that want the lowest monthly cost and fee reporting.

Our recommendation

  • Online and in-store, with targeting by market, region or customer: Bony.
  • High order volume on a flat price: Upcharge.
  • Most reviews in a close Bony alternative: VOL.
  • Small online-only store testing fees: TackOn's 20-order free plan.
  • Lowest cost with POS: Feesly.

Whichever app you choose, test the fee in cart and checkout on a draft theme before going live. Check that the fee name is clear and that the total matches what you expect.

Related guides

Share this article

B
Written by Bony Team
Expert insights for your business

Want to learn more?

Explore related Shopify tools and more practical ecommerce guidance.

Ready to Transform Your Shopify Store?

Discover our powerful apps and start growing your business today